florida affirmative defenses to breach of contract florida affirmative defenses to breach of contract

Statutory Construction What does the Statute Mean? See Grobman v. Posey, 863 So.2d 1230 (Fla. 4th DCA 2003)). One of the most common business disputes is a breach of contract dispute. However, in addition to denials in your breach of contract suit answer, your answer should likely include affirmative defenses. 3d 102 (Fla. 2010), the Florida Supreme Court held that defendant's reliance need not be "justifiable." . Gulisano Law, PLLC. With respect to mistake as an affirmative defense, the Restatement of contracts states that where a mistake of both parties at the time a contract was made as to a basic assumption on which the contract as made has a material effect on the agreed exchange of performances, the contract is voidable by the adversely affected party unless he bears the risk of the mistake. If they then sue you for the original amount owed before the settlement, you can assert the affirmative defense of Accord and Satisfaction. In response, APCO filed its Answer, which included multiple affirmative defenses to Zitting's breach of contract claim. Breach of Implied in Law Contract, Breach: 07. Honest, hardworking sellers should not be held hostage to the unreasonable expectations of an overly demanding buyer. Below are a few examples of defenses to breaches of contract, not all defenses. Suite 140-E There are many different defenses to a breach of contract action - reasons why you were not able to do what you were supposed to do under the contract, or why there never was a contract in the first place. Prior to trial, the plaintiff settled with two of the defendants for a total of $100,000 and gave the defendants releases. ANSWER to Complaint with Affirmative Defenses by Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated. Rule 1.110 - GENERAL RULES OF PLEADING. Affirmative Defenses A defendant should raise as many legal defenses as possible. Today, a minor is not recognized to possessed full legal capacity to contract. If so, the breach of fiduciary duty claim may be dismissed as duplicative. Defending against breach of contract claims requires a meticulous review of your situation and a full exploration of your options and available defenses. Section 400 Substantive Instructions Fla. 2014) (It is a fundamental principle of Florida contract law that a material breach by one party excuses the performance by the other.). Failure to meet a deadline is more likely to qualify as a material breach where the contract specifically provides that time is essential or time is of the essence. See e.g., Legacy Place Apartment Homes, LLC v. PGA Gateway, L.T.D., 65 So. Romy B. Jurado, Esq. With a Dead Body, Tortious Interference: 4. Unlike the Florida state court authority on this issue, there are numerous federal District Court opinions supporting the position that a plaintiff asserting a breach of contract claim and declaratory judgment claim in the same action cannot state a "bona fide need" for the declaratory judgment when the breach of contract claim has not been But, where there are separate and distinct claims involving different elements of damages, set-off is inappropriate. . 3d at 1309 (quotation omitted) (emphasis added) (There are few principles of contract law better established, or more uniformly acknowledged, than the rule that when a contract not fully performed on either side is continued in spite of a known excuse, the right to rely upon the known excuse is waived.). See e.g., Edwards Waters College, Inc. v. Johnson, 707 So. 13. Most defenses to a breach of contract claim are referred to as "affirmative defenses." As a legal matter, this means that the party raising the defense (the person sued for breach of contract) has the burden of proving the defense, if the dispute goes to trial. . These are called "affirmative defenses." There many affirmative defenses available. 10. Section 200 Preliminary Instructions Check and see if the claim for breach of fiduciary duty is merely a restated breach of contract claim. . See, e.g., Branch Banking & Trust Co. v. S&S Development, Inc., 2015 WL 12683834 *8 (M.D. Another affirmative defense can arise if you reached a settlement agreement with the credit card company and fully performed your obligations under that agreement. Remedies for a Breach of Contract in Florida; 2023 Malescu Law P.A. It is a hard defense to prevail on because it is akin to fraud: Unclean hands is an equitable defense much like fraud. After that, the party must prove that the promise was broken. In order for a plaintiff to win a lawsuit against you, they have to prove each of the elements of their claim. Seventh Affirmative Defense 7. The materiality requirement mandates that the breached contractual duty must be of significant importance. | Web design by Silva Heeren. And lastly, the party must prove that it has sustained damages, such as financial losses, due breach of contract. Personal Jurisdiction and Florida Courts Two-Prong Analysis, Yes, Lawsuits are an Inconvenience, but this does NOT Mean You get Inconvenience Damages, Evidentiary Hearing Warranted before Compelling Non-Signatories to Arbitration, Mutual Mistake or Unilateral Mistake in Contract, Employees Premise Liability Claim Barred by Disclaimer / Release in Employment Agreement, Comparative Fault Applies when Substance of the Action is Sounded in Negligence, Work Product Document and Withholding of Documents Based on Doctrine, Nature of Disclosure under Floridas Public Whistleblower Act, Declaratory Relief in Insurance Coverage Dispute, Statute of Limitations Accrual for Breach of Contract, Enforce Settlement Agreement OR Breach of Settlement Agreement, Objecting and/or Refusing to Participate in Employers Activity in Violation of a Law, Rule, or Regulation under Floridas Whistleblower Act, Quick Note: Obtaining a Default Final Judgment, Appealing a Protective Order that Precludes You from Deposing Material Witness, Tortious Interference with Business Relationship and Two Defense Privileges, Possible or Speculative Events do Not Give Rise to Fraudulent Nondisclosure, Prevailing Party in Civil Action Entitled to Recover Costs, Properly Exercising the Right of First Refusal, Reasonable Attorneys Fees Expert when Attorneys Fees are the Damages, Prejudgment Interest for Economic Damages is Predicated on the Loss Theory, Take Advantage of Video Conference Consultations with an Attorney. We also happen to be Florida breach of warranty attorneys. AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES 26. In a breach of a contract dispute, the party raising the defense is responsible for proving the defense in court. Arbitrability of a Dispute Does a Judge or Arbitrator Decide? Click here for a more detailed description of how I, asan experienced Florida debt attorney, can defend your debt collection lawsuit. Personal Jurisdiction and Florida Courts Two-Prong Analysis, Yes, Lawsuits are an Inconvenience, but this does NOT Mean You get Inconvenience Damages, Evidentiary Hearing Warranted before Compelling Non-Signatories to Arbitration, Mutual Mistake or Unilateral Mistake in Contract, Employees Premise Liability Claim Barred by Disclaimer / Release in Employment Agreement, Comparative Fault Applies when Substance of the Action is Sounded in Negligence, Work Product Document and Withholding of Documents Based on Doctrine, Nature of Disclosure under Floridas Public Whistleblower Act, Declaratory Relief in Insurance Coverage Dispute, Statute of Limitations Accrual for Breach of Contract, Enforce Settlement Agreement OR Breach of Settlement Agreement, Objecting and/or Refusing to Participate in Employers Activity in Violation of a Law, Rule, or Regulation under Floridas Whistleblower Act, Quick Note: Obtaining a Default Final Judgment, Appealing a Protective Order that Precludes You from Deposing Material Witness, Tortious Interference with Business Relationship and Two Defense Privileges, Possible or Speculative Events do Not Give Rise to Fraudulent Nondisclosure, Prevailing Party in Civil Action Entitled to Recover Costs, Properly Exercising the Right of First Refusal, Reasonable Attorneys Fees Expert when Attorneys Fees are the Damages, Prejudgment Interest for Economic Damages is Predicated on the Loss Theory, Take Advantage of Video Conference Consultations with an Attorney. As Gold says, "There are certainly defenses to breach of contract." Brain Injuries Sustained in Florida Car Accidents, Defense of Domestic Violence Charges in Martin County, Free Stuart FL Personal Injury Lawyer Advice. For many reasons, it is imperative you retain the services of a forceful and thorough advocate who can protect your interests. Plaintiffs are unable to recover under a theory of interference with contractual relations without demonstrating a viable contract with a third party, that the Defendant was aware of such a contract and interfered with the third party contract. Below are the elements the person or business entity who filed against you must prove in court in order to succeed on a breach of contract dispute. Call (561) 953-6662. This means that if the contract in violates state or federal law, then it is automatically barred. The party must prove the existence of an enforceable contract. In California, offset is an affirmative defense to a claim for breach of contract. If this is a defense you want to try to prove, remember you will need to factually prove the bad unclean hands conduct and the elements to satisfy the defense. An attorney client relationship is not established by submitting an email or a form from this website. We are your Breach of Warranty Claims and Defenses Lawyers in Florida Buyers deserve to get the ownership, value, and quality that they deserve when making a purchase. There are several ways in which you can defend a lawsuit filed against you by a credit card company, debt collector, bank, auto finance company and other plaintiffs. The invaluable online tool for litigation and transactional attorneys. This is typically pleaded in an answer to the Complaint in the affirmative defense section. Lets break this down as applied to the above hypothetical. Affirmative Defenses to Breach of Warranty. 2023 The Florida Bar. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 801 Northpoint Parkway (See also this, Value of Restrictive Covenant when Moving for Permanent Injunction, Reasonable Attorneys Fee Hearing Does Attorney Need to Testify at Hearing, Word to the Wise: File Your Notice of Appeal TIMELY, Contract is Not Hearsay; It has Independent Legal Significance, Voluntarily Dismissing a Lawsuit that Gives Rise to Attorneys Fees (Oh No! The failure to meet contractual deadlines may or may not be deemed material. 3d 1300, 1309 (S.D. It is asserted, but not really a defense a party can ever prove. Here, I will discuss typical defences if you have been sued for a breach of contract in Florida. (561) 948-5589, Copyright 2023 Van Riper & Nies AT&T, Sprint & T-Mobile Users Can Dial **LAWYERS, Breach of Warranty Claims & Defenses in Florida, Economic Injury Claims and Defenses in Commercial Litigation, Computer Fraud Abuse and Hacking Claims and Defenses (CFAA), Unfair or Deceptive Business Practice Claims and Defense in Florida, Interference with Contractual or Business Relations Claims and Defense, Intellectual Property Claims and Intellectual Property Defense, Trademark Infringement Claims and Trademark Infringement Lawsuit Defense, Cybersquatting Claims and Defenses Under the Anti Cyber Squatting Protection Act (ACPA). See, e.g., MDS (Canada), Inc. v. Rad Source Techns., Inc., 720 F.3d 833, 850 (11th Cir. Corp. of DC v. Caylao, 130 So. Failure to Produce a Written Contract: Sometimes, the other side can protest that an oral agreement is grounds for a breach of contract. Personal Injury, Divorce & Criminal Lawyers in Stuart, Delray Beach, Boca Raton, Port St Lucie, Stuart Deerfield Beach West Palm Beach Delray Beach Boca Raton, Commercial Litigation By Tim Nies, Esq. For example, in Covelli Family, L.P. v. ABG5, LLC, 977 So. There are defenses to contract that arise at the time the contract is formed and other defenses that may arise after the contract is formed and can be raised to avoid contractual obligation such as change of circumstances which render performance impracticable. Under this defense, the person or entity being accused of a breach of contract argues that the other party is not entitled to a remedy under Florida. The impossibility of performance means that the defending party is unable to perform according to the provisions of the contract due to an unforeseen incident. To determine whether the breach is material, there are certain criteria one may consult when undertaking such a task [including]: (1) the extent to which the injured party will be deprived of the benefit which can reasonably be expected; (2) the extent to which the injured party can be adequately compensated for the part of the benefit of which she will be deprived; (3) the extent to which the breaching party will suffer forfeiture; (4) the likelihood that the breaching party will cure; and (5) the extent to which the behavior of the breaching party comports with the standards of good faith and fair dealing. Id. In some cases, these affirmative defenses can also allow you to bring a counterclaim against the debt collector or its attorneys. In Florida, the prosecution of a residential mortgage foreclosure action must be by the owner and holder of the . We are your Breach of Warranty Claims and Defenses Lawyers in Florida. Often a plaintiff is required to make the claim within a specific time after . 3d at 1297 (Price or compensation is typically an essential term of a contract.). In addition, even if a warranty is waived or limited, there are often still claims that may be made if the waivers or limitations are unfair or unreasonable. The description of a dependent/independent covenant does sound similar to the definition of materiality and some cases treat these requirements interchangeably. 2d 470, 471 (Fla. 4th DCA 2003). A prior breach can also be implicitly waived by the parties conduct. The main defenses include: Unilateral or Mutual Mistake; Misrepresentation and Fraud; Duress and Undue Influence; Unconscionability; Lack of Consent; Impossibility or Impracticability; Frustration of Purpose; and Statute of Frauds In those cases, you may be able to not only win your case, but recover money from the other side. Hamilton, 6 F. Supp. noun. For example, four (4) widgets at $8.00 each would be a material breach of a contract for four (4) widgets at $4.00 each. Rescission. See, e.g., Focus Mgmt. In an affirmative defense, you do not contest the claims of the plaintiff; however, you do contest that there were additional factors that render the breach of contract claim irrelevant. See Digesu v. 11 Suite 375 Fla. 2002) (emphasis added). An affirmative defense is a reason given by the defendant for why the plaintiff should not win the lawsuit, even if what the plaintiff says is true. Florida Rules of Civil Procedure. This means that the party was unable to abide by the terms of the contract as the incident made it impossible for the party to do so. Doe/Roe Defendants. See Beefy Trail, Inc. v. Beefy King Intl, Inc., 267 So. (2) At trial, if any defendant shows the court that the plaintiff, or any person lawfully on her or his behalf, has delivered a release or covenant not to sue to any person, firm, or corporation in partial satisfaction of the damages sued for, the court shall set off this amount from the amount of any judgment to which the plaintiff would be otherwise entitled at the time of rendering judgment and enter judgment accordingly. whose benefit the action is brought. The second element, which requires that the breach be material, bears on the nature and impact of the breach. Failure of Consideration: A contract is only enforceable by Plaintiff if Plaintiff . For instance, say a plaintiff sues three defendants in negligence for the same damage. STATUTORY CLAIMS UNDER THE INSURANCE CODE & DPTA There are several claims that are commonly This is a complicated defense. v. Domino, 896 So. Directors Liabilities and Responsibilities, Joint Ventures and International Business Agreements, Acquisition and Sale of U.S. or Foreign Companies, Fiduciary duties of officers and directors, Litigation, arbitration and risk management, E-2 Visa Requirements, Eligibility and Benefits, EB-1C Multinational Manager and Executive, P-1 Visa Athletes and Entertainment Groups. EIGHTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE (Doe/Roe Defendants) 8. Denied. Preliminary Sections In the case of duress and undue influence, a party was forced to sign a contract against his or her will. there must have been a prior breach of the contract; the contractual provision breached must be material to the contract; the contractual provision breached must be a dependent covenant not a independent covenant; and. This is a strong defense as the person or entity forfeits its consensual partnership in the contract. Generally, in the United States, some of the affirmative defenses to breach of contract include: Lack of capacity. 3d 1291, 1299 (11th Cir. See Taylor v. Genesee & Wyoming, Inc., 2015 WL 12683821 *5 (M.D. See e.g., AVVA-BC, LLC v. Amiel, 25 So. A Statute of Limitations is a state law that prohibits a plaintiff from winning a lawsuit if they simply wait too long to enforce their rights. The doctrine of avoidable consequences is an affirmative defense that can be used in certain property damage lawsuits. Affirmative defenses are reasons the defendant gives why a plaintiff in a case should not win. These defenses are meant to help the defense side win the case even if the plaintiff's claims of breach of contract are true. 3d at 1309 (Whether a particular breach is material raises an issue of fact.). In those circumstances, common law contract principles may provide a defense to claims of contractual breach caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Extra-Contractual Damages cannot be Recovered against Property Insurer Absent Bad Faith Claim, In Ruling on Motion to Compel Arbitration, Trial Court Must Determine whether Parties Bound by Arbitration Provision, Recording Documents in Public Records to put Others on Constructive Notice, Proposals for Settlement and Dismissals WITHOUT PREJUDICE, Just because You Recovered an Affirmative Judgment does NOT Mean you Are the Prevailing Party for Purposes of Attorneys Fees, PLEAD SUFFICIENT ALLEGATIONS SUPPORTING PERSONAL JURISDICTION, Pleading the 5th Amendment Right Against Self Incrimination in a Civil Dispute, Owner can Testify as to the Value of His Property, Piercing the Corporate Veil is NO Easy Feat, 3-Step Process to Determine Production of Document under Trade Secret Privilege, Loss of Future Earning Capacity Damages Must be Proven with Reasonable Degree of Certainty, Declaration Cannot Take Away Common Elements in a Condominium, Properly Alleging a Trade Secret Misappropriation Claim under Florida Law. Breach of Joint Venture Agreement, Breach: 04. If you are interested in speaking to a Jimerson Birr lawyer or want general information about the firm, our practice areas, lawyers, publications, or events, please contact us via email or telephone for assistance at (904) 389-0050. A covenant is dependent where it goes to the whole consideration of the contract; where it is such an essential part of the bargain that the failure of it must be considered as destroying the entire contract; or where it is such an indispensable part of what both parties intended that the contract would not have been made with the covenant omitted. Steak House, Inc., 65 So. All Rights Reserved. 2d 736, 737 (Fla. 1953). Unilateral and mutual mistake. Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap. If you are located in Central Florida (including Seminole County, Orange County, Lake County, Brevard County, Volusia County or Flagler County), we would be honored if you would call us at 386-444-3032 for a free consultation. Because breach of warranty is based on a contract between the parties, the defendant can require the plaintiff to do certain things to obtain a remedy. The existence of fraud, mutual mistake, false representation, impossibility of performance, or other ground for rescission or cancellation; Plaintiff has rescinded the contract and notified defendant of such rescission; If the plaintiff has received benefits from the contract, the plaintiff should further allege an offer to restore . That one call can mean the difference between winning and losing your lawsuit. One such affirmative defense is the Statute of Limitations. The party asserting the defense must also prove three other elements: (1) reliance on the conduct; (2) relation to the litigation; (3) resulting in an injury. Qadir, supra (citation omitted). Section 100 Oaths The objective is to prevent the plaintiff from obtaining a windfall by obtaining overlapping compensation for the same damages. Click the icon above to call Gulisano Law now for a free consultation. One of these affirmative defenses was a failure of conditions-precedent. The remaining defendant proceeds to trial but a) thinks its liability is no more than $100,000 and b) wants to reap the benefit of the $100,000 already obtained by the plaintiff from the other two defendants. Model Form of Verdict for Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing, Form 416.25. 3d 955, 960 (Fla. 5th DCA 2015) (emphasis added). One affirmative defense to breach of contract is lack of legal capacity to contract such infancy and mental incompetence. If someone is forced to enter into a contract by force or threat, there will be no contract as the force or threat deprives that person or entity of the ability to choose. The most common defenses to enforcement of a contract or liability for damages are: Enforcement of the contract would violate public policy. Regarding the negligence count, we will allege that Bernie was a trespasser and so was not owed a duty of . DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL Lorit demands a jury trial. The prior breach doctrine only applies if the other party breached the contract first, or prior to, any alleged breach by the party seeking to utilize the doctrine.See e.g., No. To achieve an account stated, the agreement must amount to a recognition of a debt by a party, with a promise, express or implied, to . ~ From the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, About Contract & Business Jury Instructions, Florida's Standards for Imposing Lawyer Sanctions, Section 600 Substantive Instructions General, Appendix AHow to Write and Use Jury Instruction in Civil Cases, 416.3 Contract Formation Essential Factual Elements, 416.4 Breach of Contract Essential Factual Elements, 416.9 Contract Formation Revocation of Offer, 416.11 Contract Formation Acceptance by Silence or Conduct, 416.15 Interpretation Meaning of Ordinary Words, 416.16 Interpretation Meaning of Disputed Technical or Special Words, 416.17 Interpretation Construction of Contract as a Whole, 416.18 Interpretation Construction by Conduct, 416.20 Interpretation Construction Against Drafter, 416.21 Existence of Condition Precedent Disputed, 416.22 Occurrence of Agreed Condition Precedent, 416.24 Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing, 416.25 Affirmative Defense Mutual Mistake of Fact, 416.26 Affirmative Defense Unilateral Mistake of Fact, 416.27 Affirmative Defense Undue Influence, 416.28 Affirmative Defense Fraud in the Inducement, 416.29 Affirmative Defense Negligent Misrepresentation, 416.32 Affirmative Defense Statute of Limitations, 416.33 Affirmative Defense Equitable Estoppel, 416.35 Affirmative Defense Judicial Estoppel, 416.36 Affirmative Defense Ratification, 416.42 Breach of Duty to Disclose- Residential, 504.4 Damages for Complete Destruction to Business, 504.5 Owners Damages for Breach of Contract to Construct Improvements on Real Property, 504.7 Buyers Damages for Breach of Contract for Sale of Real Property, 504.8 Sellers Damages for Breach of Contract to Purchase Real Property, 504.10 Present Cash Value of Future Damages, How to Write and Use Jury Instruction in Civil Cases, Form 416.2 Model Form of Verdict for Third-Party Beneficiary of Contract Claim, Form 416.3 Model Form of Verdict for Formation of Contract, Form 416.4. Better Legal Talent and Quality Work than the Large Firms. In order to be successful, the plaintiff must prove all three elements mentioned above. ), Equitable Relief: One seeking Equity MUST do Equity, Exculpatory Clauses will be Strictly Construed to Determine Enforceability, Do Yourself a Favor: Get a Court Reporter at that Impactful Hearing, Real Estate Brokers are NOT Immune from Liability, Res Judicata and 4 Requirements that Must be Demonstrated, Writ of Prohibition to Prevent Trial Court from Exceeding Jurisdiction, Directed Verdict Granted where No View of Evidence Could Support Jury Verdict, Petition for Writ of Mandamus Directing Trial Court to Take Action, Considerations: Independent Tort Doctrine and Claim Known as Equitable Accounting, Waiver is a Voluntary Relinquishment of a Known Right that Must be Proven with a Clear Showing, Dismissal Without Prejudice does NOT Trigger Attorneys Fees under Proposal for Settlements, Bert Harris Act and Competing Motions for Summary Judgment, Plaintiff MUST Confer Direct Benefit on Defendant to Prove Unjust Enrichment, You Cannot Intentionally Render Moot a Plaintiffs Lawsuit, Apparent Authority of Agent to Bind Principal, Serving the Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) to Perfect a First-Party Bad Faith Insurance Claim, Breach of Express Contract is Exception to Sovereign Immunity, Moving for and Challenging a Protective Order under the Apex Doctrine, Purchase-and-Sale Contract: Your Right to Modify Them, Premise Liability and Duty Owed to Business Invitees, Recovering Attorneys Fees in Litigating the Amount of Attorneys Fees, Business Interruption due to COVID-19 NOT Covered under Commercial Property Insurance Policy, Foreseeability and the Duty Element of a Negligence Claim, Post-Judgment Receiver Appointed to Collect on Behalf of Judgment Creditor, Reminder: Not Every Breach is a Material Breach of Contract, Adding a Non-Party Fabre Defendant to the Verdict Form, 3-Step Process for Objections to Trade Secrets, Attorneys Fees to Prevailing Party Under FDUTPA Claim are PERMISSIVE, Contractually Disclaiming a Fraud Claim (Possible, but not Easy to do), Floridas Single Publication Rule (and Defamation Claims), Reasonable Time to Accept Settlement Offer (is a Question of Fact), Contingency Fee Multiplier Must Establish the Relevant Market Factor, Business Judgment Rule Designed to Shield Directors from Personal Liability, Ambiguity in Insurance Policy Interpreted in Favor of Insured, Pure Bill of Discovery NOT for Purposes of Fishing Expedition, Partition Action does Not Result in Money Damages Against a Party, Consider Prevailing Party Attorneys Fees before Voluntarily Dismissing Case, Confession of Judgment does Not Start the Clock to File Motion for Attorneys Fees, Quick Note: Motion for Protective Order Reviewed Under Abuse of Discretion Standard of Review, There are NO Magic Buzz Words to Effectuate an Assignment, Presuit Appraisal Requirement under Bert J. Harris Act, Determining whether Lis Pendens Against Property is Appropriate Fair Nexus, Recovering Attorneys Fees Incurred on Partys Behalf, To Pierce Corporate Veil, there Needs to be Sufficient Findings of Improper Conduct, Timely Moving for Trial De Novo after Non-Binding Arbitration Award, Attorneys Fees do Not have to be Quantified in Proposal for Settlement, A Bad Deal does NOT Make It an Unlawful Deal, Dismissal of Complaint (Action under Floridas Public Whistleblower Act) for Failure to State Cause of Action, Duty Element of Negligence Did Defendants Conduct Foreseeably Create Broader Zone of Risk, Trier of Fact Determines Weight of the Evidence, Oops!